In the opinion of the editors at Black BaseballCom, the following players in the old Negro Baseball Leagues are worthy of being honored by induction into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, New York.
Players are listed by position and ranked in order of their abilities at each position.
| Catcher Biz Mackey Louis Sandtop |
First Base Ben Taylor Mules Suttles |
Second Base Bingo DeMoss Newt Allen Sammy T. Hughes |
| Pitchers Smokey Joe Williams Bullet Rogan Dick Redding Hilton Smith Ray Brown Bill Byrd |
Shortstop Dick Lundy John Beckwith Third Base |
Outfield Pete Hill Christobal Torriente Turkey Stearnes Spot Poles Bill Wright Willard Brown |